• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

nSiteful Web Builders

Building a Better Web - One Site at a Time.

  • Home
  • About
    • Testimonials
    • Resources
  • Web Sites
  • Online Marketing
  • WordPress Support
    • Customized WordPress Training
    • 60-for-60 Sessions
  • Web Applications
  • Blog
    • Archive Listing Minimalistic
    • Blog Articles Grouped by Category
    • Case Studies
    • General
    • Portfolio
    • Reviews
    • Snippets
    • Techniques
  • Contact Jeff
    • Purchase Retainer Consulting Hours
    • About Retainer Consulting Hours

By Jeff Cohan, June 6, 2013

Enough already with the formulaic blog titles

Scanning my newsfeeds tonight and finding way too many salesey, hypey headlines linking to boringly bland blog posts, I was overcome by a sudden and strong visceral dislike for the formulaic, overly-clever blog titles that are everywhere on the Web these days and which, admittedly, until tonight, I have been all too inclined to emulate (and recommend to others).

Clever HeadlinesI’m talking about blog titles that begin like this:

  • 14 Reasons..
  • 23 things…
  • The 6 Things…
  • 12 Ways to…
  • 10 Reasons…
  • 9 Scientifically-Backed…
  • 8 Tips for…
  • 7 Ways to…
  • 14 Steps to…
  • A 7-Point Plan for…
  • The 13 Secrets…
  • 42 Elements of…
  • 3 Simple…
  • The 12-Minute Technique…
  • 22 Ways…

So I opened a blank document in my word processor to draft a new rant.

I typed out a working title on the first line (copyblogger is starting to make me sick) and then turned to the Web to see what, if anything, likeminded others have written.

I googled my working title, fully expecting an exact match. That didn’t happen.

But, man, was I ever close.

Without further ado, allow me to present a marvelous article by Neil James entitled, Copyblogger ‘Magnetic’ Headlines Make Me Ill, which says what I wanted to say better than I could have said it.

If you need convincing, I offer some money quotes below (emphasis added).

(I think you’ll also like Neil’s analogy to hockey’s neutral zone trap, which I won’t try to explain here.)

[H]eadlines are supposed to be more than a cynical tool for eliciting clicks – they’re a promise. How often do these “magnetic” headlines actually offer content of [commensurate] value to their promise? Not often in my experience.

And when crappy content farms like Mashable or TechCrunch (and those sites are content farms) continually write checks with their headlines that their hack writers can’t cash, they debase the art of headline writing.

and

Far too often, digital marketers imply that cheap tactics – clever headlines, over-optimized copy, excessive commenting, obsessive Tweet scheduling – are vital to building a strong social media brand.

No doubt, those things matter, but they pale in comparison to being interesting.

What’s much harder, and where the digerati media of the day have failed us, is that being legitimately interesting is a sizable commitment and an objective that cannot be reached by cheap tactics alone.

I think Neil nailed it. (Go ahead, read the article.)

What do you think?

Related Posts

  1. How to Create Tooltips with CSS (Only)
  2. Fun with CSS3 Multiple Backgrounds
  3. CSS Descendant Selectors
  4. Bring your Facebook Fan Page to your Web site
  5. How to use Advanced Custom Fields with Genesis
  • Choose the best match.

Written by Jeff Cohan · Categorized: General · Tagged: Content Marketing

  • Choose the best match.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Jeff Cohan says

    June 11, 2013 at 12:21 pm

    Update: Although this Copyblogger post about Priming and the mere measurement effect isn’t about headlines, it’s cut from the same cloth, IMO. Namely, it advocates practices that are questionable at best. I agree that priming isn’t necessarily manipulation. But, dang, tell me that the tactics of the fictional Gallup Researcher (described — and endorsed — at the outset of the article) aren’t crazy manipulative. And then there’s the money quote:

    When it comes to the world of content marketing, you can influence the behavior of your readers, subscribers, and customers … and you can do it without them even noticing.

    What to you think?

    Reply
  2. Rick Meekins says

    June 14, 2013 at 6:35 am

    I completely concur. I still wonder about the actual effectiveness. Seems like there I so much hype about so many things with very little value that it becomes difficult to run an honest business. Think about it: this is the very reason Google ash to change its search algorithms causing all of the time. There is so much to be said for integrity!

    I wonder if it is other would-be marketers that are the main consumers of that. I read a post not too long along from someone marketing to marketers a software that would rewrite articles for them so they could reuse the content. Perhaps off topic, but what are your thoughts on that?

    Reply
    • Jeff Cohan says

      June 14, 2013 at 9:38 am

      Perhaps off topic, but what are your thoughts on [software that rewrites articles so marketers can reuse the content]?

      (Very much on topic.) I think it’s just more gaming of the system, promoting plagiarism that flies under the radar of search engines.

      Reply
  3. Mark Sand says

    June 14, 2013 at 11:46 pm

    I think George Carlin said it even better with his riffs on the “bullshit society.” Funny as hell, sadly true…

    Reply
    • Jeff Cohan says

      June 15, 2013 at 12:14 am

      Ok, Mark. YouTube link, please!

      Reply
  4. Patrick McNease says

    February 28, 2014 at 1:13 am

    As a Copyblogger visitor I would like to say that it works for them. Jeff, I do agree that some of the headlines are formulaic and well they influence a lot of bloggers (myself included). Recently I started reading work by Jeff Goins and Michael Hyatt and it has changed the way that I blog.

    I think that I will sprinkle in the formulaic headlines ever once in awhile (like once a month). From here on out I want to provide more value. Thank you for what you do.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

mailchimp signup

Subscribe to get notified when new articles are published. Unsubscribe any time. No spam. I promise. Check out my newsletter archives.

social

Twitter Facebook LinkedIn

Recent Articles

  • Use Case for Custom Post Type: “In The News” March 10, 2023
  • Create a Custom Shortcode to Display a MemberPress Membership Price ANYWHERE on Your Website February 5, 2023
  • Avoid Direct Styling; Use CSS Instead September 21, 2022
  • Blog Tags: What They Are (and What They’re Not) August 5, 2022
  • How to Create a Simple Custom Events Plugin May 24, 2022

Filter By Category/Tag

Categories

  • Case Studies (7)
  • General (61)
  • Portfolio (5)
  • Reviews (12)
  • Snippets (16)
  • Techniques (38)

Popular Tags

Advanced Custom Fields Blogging Child Themes Content Marketing CSS CSS Grid Customer Service Custom Fields Custom Post Types Diagnostics Facebook FooGallery Genesis Gutenberg HTML Images iPhone Libra Live Chat Marketing Media MemberPress MemberPress Courses mu-plugins MySQL Photo Gallery php Pinterest Plugins Post Formats Pricing Project Management Security SEO Seth Godin Shortcodes Social Networking Surveys Taxonomies Trello Twitter Video Web design Web forms WordPress

siteground wp hosting

Web Hosting

wp101

EasyWordPresstutorialvideosforbeginners.
MemberPress CTA

Footer

Background

Web Sites | WordPress Support | Web Applications.

Formally trained in liberal arts and education (I have a B.A. in Government from Harvard and studied Secondary Education at Rutgers Graduate School), I have honed my skills in the communication arts and sciences as a teacher, trainer, instructional designer, writer, photographer, calligrapher, helpdesk manager, database programmer, and multimedia developer.

(I've also been a group counselor, waiter, bartender, bicycle messenger boy, computer salesman, carpenter's helper, financial analyst, and school board president.)

Tech

Systems since 1983.
Web sites since 1994.
PHP since 2001.
WordPress since 2007.

Contact

770-772-5134
Email Jeff
Send Money
All Ways

Copyright 2023, nSiteful Web Builders, Inc.

 

Subscribe

Pardon the interruption. I know popups can be annoying. But I’d love to have you as a subscriber.

Sign up to be notified when new articles are published. Unsubscribe any time.

* indicates required

Powered by MailChimp

×